Amazing 12-hour Tangy Cider & Mustard Grilled Chicken

If you’re like me, you want dinner on the table fast, but you never want it to taste boring. That’s why I’m so thrilled to share my Tangy Cider & Mustard Grilled Chicken recipe with you! I’m Anna, and I spend my time finding simple, flavorful chicken recipes that make everyday cooking easier and genuinely joyful. After years of backyard grilling—and yes, a few charcoal-covered disasters—I’ve cracked the code on getting that perfect balance of sweet char and juicy meat.

This marinade is unbelievably easy to throw together, but it delivers a complex, restaurant-worthy crust. Trust me, this Tangy Cider & Mustard Grilled Chicken is about to become your go-to for busy weeknights!

Assembling the Tangy Cider & Mustard Grilled Chicken Marinade

The real magic of this dish happens before it even sees the grill. It’s all about the marinade, folks! We’re balancing intense sweetness with sharp acidity, which is how you get that beautiful, caramelized crust without burning the chicken to a crisp. The brown sugar melts slightly, but the vinegar keeps everything bright and zesty. It’s a science experiment that tastes delicious!

Don’t rush this part! Whisking everything together until that brown sugar completely disappears is key. If you skip that step, you end up with pockets of undissolved sugar that will definitely scorch on the grill.

Why This Tangy Cider & Mustard Grilled Chicken Marinade Works

We’re hitting all three flavor notes here: sweet, tangy, and savory. The apple cider vinegar and citrus juices (we’re using both lime and lemon!) tenderize the chicken just a tiny bit while providing that essential tang. Then you get the deep sweetness from the brown sugar. But the real MVP is the whole grain mustard. Those little seeds add texture and a wonderful, earthy bite that cuts right through the sweetness. It just sings!

Ingredient Clarity for Tangy Cider & Mustard Grilled Chicken

When you’re measuring out your ingredients, pay close attention to the brown sugar. You need it packed down firmly into the cup—that ensures you get the right amount of molasses flavor and sweetness for that perfect Tangy Cider & Mustard Grilled Chicken crust. Also, don’t just roughly chop that garlic; mince it finely. We want that powerful flavor infused throughout the marinade, not big chunks popping up in your bite.

Essential Equipment for Perfect Grilling

You don’t need a fancy outdoor kitchen for this chicken, but you do need a few reliable tools. First, grab a sturdy, large mixing bowl. You’ll be whisking that marinade vigorously, so make sure it can handle the job without sloshing everything onto your counter. Next, you absolutely need a good digital thermometer. This is non-negotiable for safe, juicy chicken!

Finally, you need your heat source. Whether it’s a gas grill, charcoal setup, or even a heavy cast-iron grill pan on your stovetop, make sure it heats evenly. Remember to oil those grates well before the chicken hits the heat!

Step-by-Step: Preparing the Tangy Cider & Mustard Grilled Chicken

Okay, now for the fun part! We’ve mixed our zesty, sweet liquid gold; now we introduce it to the chicken thighs. Remember, we’re using boneless, skinless thighs here because they stay incredibly juicy on the grill, which is perfect for this slightly sticky marinade. If you use breasts, just watch them like a hawk, okay?

Mixing and Marinating the Chicken

Once your marinade is smooth—seriously, whisk until you can’t feel any graininess from the sugar—it’s time to introduce the chicken. I prefer using a heavy-duty zip-top bag for this. Dump the chicken in, pour that marinade over it, and seal it up, making sure to press out as much air as possible. Now, you need to massage the bag gently. Really work that marinade into every nook and cranny of the chicken. You want them completely coated!

Here’s where patience pays off. The recipe says 4 hours minimum, and that’s fine if you’re in a jam. But if you can manage it, let this mixture hang out in the fridge for the full 12 hours. That extra time lets the vinegar and mustard really penetrate the meat, making it tender and deeply flavorful. Don’t let it go past 12 hours, though, or the acid might start breaking down the texture too much.

Grilling Techniques for Tangy Cider & Mustard Grilled Chicken

Preheat your grill—we’re aiming for a nice medium heat, about 350°F to 375°F. You want it hot enough to sear, but not so hot that the sugar burns instantly. Before the chicken goes on, brush those grates with just a little vegetable oil. This is crucial because the brown sugar in the marinade creates a glaze that loves to stick!

When you pull the chicken out of the bag, let the excess marinade drip off. Don’t wipe it clean! We want that flavor, but if it’s dripping wet, it will smoke and char way too fast. Lay the thighs down carefully on the hot grates. Now, watch them closely—I mean it! The sugar content means these can go from perfect to black in seconds. If you see the edges getting too dark too fast, back that heat down immediately! We’re looking for about 6 to 8 minutes per side.

Checking for Doneness and Resting

This is the most important safety step, so please don’t skip it! You must use a reliable meat thermometer. Stick it into the thickest part of the chicken thigh. We are looking for an internal temperature of 165°F. That’s the magic number for poultry safety!

Once they hit 165°F, pull them straight off the grill and move them to a clean platter. Don’t start slicing them right away! Cover them loosely with foil and let them rest for about five minutes. This resting time lets all those delicious juices redistribute throughout the meat. If you cut them too soon, all that wonderful moisture from our Tangy Cider & Mustard Grilled Chicken marinade will just run out onto your plate instead of staying in the chicken. Trust me on the resting!

Tips for Success When Grilling

Even with the best marinade, grilling can toss you a curveball. My biggest piece of advice is managing your heat control. If you get a nasty flare-up from dripping fat, quickly move the chicken to a cooler part of the grill—the “indirect” side—while the flames die down. Don’t just stand there hoping for the best! If you want more grilling inspiration, check out my Pinterest page for more ideas.

Because we are using thighs, they cook a bit more evenly than big, thick breasts. But if you find your chicken pieces are all different sizes, try to put the smaller ones on the grill last, or pull them off early. This helps ensure everything is perfectly done at the same time. For other easy chicken options, you might enjoy my recipe for easy creamy oven baked chicken thighs recipe.

Also, don’t overcrowd the grill! Give each piece some breathing room. If you stack them too close together, the heat can’t circulate properly, and you end up steaming the chicken instead of searing it. A good sear is what locks in all that fabulous flavor from the marinade.

Storing and Reheating Your Tangy Cider & Mustard Grilled Chicken

Even though this chicken disappears fast at our house, sometimes we have leftovers, and that’s a good thing! Because the marinade has sugar, the cooked chicken needs to be handled correctly so it doesn’t get sticky or dry when you reheat it. I always slice up any extras before storing them; it makes reheating much faster! If you are looking for other ways to use chicken thighs, consider my skillet bang bang chicken thighs.

For the best texture, avoid microwaving if you can. The grill pan method works wonders for bringing back that slightly seared exterior. If you’re using frozen leftovers, make sure they thaw completely in the fridge overnight before trying to reheat them.

Storage and Reheating Guide for Leftover Grilled Chicken

Storage Method	Duration	Reheating Tip
Refrigeration (Airtight Container)	3 to 4 days	Reheat quickly in a hot skillet or grill pan for 2-3 minutes per side until warmed through.
Freezing (Airtight Container/Bag)	Up to 2 months	Thaw in the refrigerator overnight. Reheat using the skillet method or bake at 350°F for 10 minutes.

Frequently Asked Questions About Tangy Cider & Mustard Grilled Chicken

I get a lot of questions about tweaks since everyone wants to make this recipe their own! Here are the most common things folks ask me when they are planning their Tangy Cider & Mustard Grilled Chicken.

Q1. What if I don’t have dark brown sugar? Can I use white sugar?
Honestly, I strongly advise against it. White sugar doesn’t have that rich molasses flavor that pairs so beautifully with the vinegar and mustard. If you absolutely must substitute, use an equal amount of light brown sugar. If you only have white granulated sugar, add about a teaspoon of molasses to the marinade to try and mimic that depth.

Q2. My marinade seems thin. Should I thicken it before adding the chicken?
Nope! Don’t try to thicken it up. The liquid is supposed to be thin so it coats the meat evenly in the bag and doesn’t create a thick sludge on the grill. If you want a thicker glaze *after* grilling, just reserve about two tablespoons of the marinade before adding the raw chicken to a small saucepan. Boil that reserved portion rapidly for about 3 minutes until it thickens slightly, then drizzle it over the finished, rested chicken.

Can I Substitute Chicken Breasts for Thighs in the Tangy Cider & Mustard Grilled Chicken Recipe?

Yes, you totally can use boneless, skinless chicken breasts! They are lower in fat, so they can dry out faster, which is why I love the thighs for this recipe. If you switch to breasts, you need to watch the grill time carefully. Since breasts are usually thicker or leaner, start checking them around the 5-minute mark per side. They should still hit 165°F internally, but they might be done slightly faster than the thighs.

Q3. Can I use dried parsley instead of fresh for garnish?
Sure! If you can’t find fresh parsley, which adds such a nice pop of color and fresh flavor at the end, just use about one teaspoon of dried parsley flakes mixed into the marinade instead. Adding it to the marinade allows the dried herb time to rehydrate and release its flavor.

Sharing Your Tangy Cider & Mustard Grilled Chicken Experience

I truly hope this recipe brings some easy, zesty flavor to your dinner table this week. If you made this Tangy Cider & Mustard Grilled Chicken, please leave a quick rating below! I love hearing how it turned out for your family, and seeing your photos always makes my day.

Print